I had a mostly good experience with Goldin submitting several cards/lots. The one major issue I had, they sent one of my cards to PSA for grading and it came back Auth/altered. That happens sometimes and best to crack it and submit to BGS or SGC. It was an MJ Tiffany part of a set. The Kobe came back with PSA 9 and the MJ was even nicer. Goldin refused to crack and resubmit and also refused to send it back to me to do it myself. So that probably cost me around $2000 (may more if it would've gem'd which it might have). Lesson: always get it graded yourself before you send it to Goldin.
Great review. I’ve heard a lot of different experiences with Goldin but it’s nice to have something of a review without any emotion involved. Can’t wait to see who you do next and I’m looking forward to your eventual Fanatics Collect review.
I had a mostly good experience with Goldin submitting several cards/lots. The one major issue I had, they sent one of my cards to PSA for grading and it came back Auth/altered. That happens sometimes and best to crack it and submit to BGS or SGC. It was an MJ Tiffany part of a set. The Kobe came back with PSA 9 and the MJ was even nicer. Goldin refused to crack and resubmit and also refused to send it back to me to do it myself. So that probably cost me around $2000 (may more if it would've gem'd which it might have). Lesson: always get it graded yourself before you send it to Goldin.
Really great advice. Thanks for sharing!
This is so helpful! Planning to use an auction house for a Superfractor — Would love to see your grade on Heritage House. All the best.
Great review. I’ve heard a lot of different experiences with Goldin but it’s nice to have something of a review without any emotion involved. Can’t wait to see who you do next and I’m looking forward to your eventual Fanatics Collect review.
Thanks!
Fanatics Collect is definitely on the list!
Really interesting and useful concept for a series. Looking forward to following along!
Thanks!
Appreciate the kind words!
Heritage is on the list :)